Updated 27 Jan 2009

WIRKSWORTH Parish Records 1600-1900

Return to Front Page

MENU

Last

Photo 587

Next

Magpie Mine near Sheldon, OS ref SK 173-682.

Aerial of the Magpie Mine. [Paste 53.210269, -1.742961 into Google Earth]

Dates:
Photo taken:
Size:
Source:

Click on photo for enlargement (on CD only)
Have any more information about this photo? 
Please e-mail the author on:


Murder at Red Soil Mine

The Magpie Mine is one of the most famous and spectacular lead mines in the Peak District, but it had its dark side. In 1834 eighteen of the Magpie miners were charged with wilful murder of three Red Soil miners. Following a year in prison and a lengthy court case, the Magpie miners were acquitted of the charge of murder owing to conflicting evidence and the lack of intent. The Red Soil widows supposedly put a curse on the mine. The mine was dogged by troubles throughout the rest of the 19th century.

The Magpie Mine, just South of Sheldon, is the only one with a significant part of its building still standing, having been taken into the care of the Peak District Mines Historical Society in 1962. The mine buildings can be seen from the Bakewell - Chelmorton road.

The mine is at the junction of the Magpie vein, the Bole vein and the Butts vein, and was only one of several mines exploiting these veins - the Red Soil Mine and the Maypitts mine lay within only a few hundred metres of the Magpie. The mine is first recorded in 1795, though the workings are probably much older. It finally ceased operations in 1958, though the working in the 1950s mined little actual lead. The heyday of the mine was in the mid 19th Century.

The proximity of other mines often led to disputes, and the Magpie Mine and the Red Soil mine disputed the working of the Bole Vein on which they both lay.

Because of a particular quirk of nature, the best lead bearing ore is situated more than 730ft underground, which happens to be 150ft below the water level. Consequently drainage has always been a problem, and so instead of digging down, the mine began to spread sideways in efforts to find richer, drier deposits. Unfortunately, these excavations eventaully led to the Magpie excavations reaching and connecting with those of a neigbouring Red Soil Mine further down the valley.

The matter was made worse by the fact that whereas the Red Soil was being worked by local men, the Magpie was at this time being mined by labour imported from Cornwall. This combiantion of factors led to many confrontations, leading to several underground battles between rival teams of miners.

The Red Soil Miners set fire to straw 400 feet below ground. The Magpie Miners retaliated by burning straw, sulphur and oil resulting in a panic when three of the Red Soil Miners suffocated.

In 1834 eighteen of the Magpie miners were charged with wilful murder of three Red Soil miners. Following a year in prison and a lengthy court case, the Magpie miners were acquitted of the charge of murder owing to conflicting evidence and the lack of intent. The Red Soil widows supposedly put a curse on the mine. The mine was dogged by troubles throughout the rest of the 19th century.

Miners from Magpie Mine tried for Murder at Derby Assize, but acquitted
1834 Richard SUTTON 35 murder at Red Soil Mine not guilty
1834 Jonathon ROWLAND 34 murder at Red Soil Mine not guilty
1834 Samuel TURNER 21 murder at Red Soil Mine not guilty
1834 Abraham BERRESFORD 36 at Red Soil Mine murder not guilty
1834 Abraham DOXEY 60 murder at Red Soil Mine not guilty
1834 Benjamin MARSDEN 45 murder at Red Soil Mine not guilty
1834 Thomas SKIDMORE 45 murder at Red Soil Mine not guilty
1834 Thomas ASHMORE 26 murder at Red Soil Mine not guilty
1834 George MALTBY 37 murder at Red Soil Mine not guilty
1834 George SUTTON 23 murder at Red Soil Mine not guilty
1834 Joseph BAKER 26 murder at Red Soil Mine not guilty
1834 James GOODWIN 31 murder at Red Soil Mine not guilty
1834 John BUNTING 21 murder at Red Soil Mine not guilty
1834 Thomas BAGSHAW 24 murder at Red Soil Mine not guilty
1834 William STONE 21 murder at Red Soil Mine not guilty
1834 Charles HARRISON 21 murder at Red Soil Mine not guilty
1834 Daniel HARRISON 46 murder at Red Soil Mine not guilty
1834 Isaac GOODWIN 27 murder at Red Soil Mine (an accessory before the fact)not guilty
Transcribed by Jean Durbin, Australia

[Click on a thumbnail to see atmospheric 800x530 images from Paul's website]
Paul Froggat writes from NZ:
I was interested in your post about the Magpie Mine. I have a professional interest in mining, as well as the usual family history in Derbyshire. I visited the Magpie Mine in early Jan 2007 hoping for some snow in the photos, but just got the cold wind and grey clouds. You might live a long way from Sheldon, but New Zealand is a bit further ..... I had previously read the story about the miners and the fires and not surprised they got off the murder charge. The b/w photo on your webpage is a good example, but just in case you are interested in others, I have put a few at http://www.frogs.co.nz/england06/magpie.htm Click on the photos for larger versions. If you would like to copy any of them, feel free. And if your want one at higher resolution, I am happy to provide.
Cheers
Paul

And thank you for all the hard work you do on your website. Like many people I find the photos and stories fascinating

    Hello John,
    I have been researching the ancestors of the MALTBY family into which my grandmother's sister married. I suspect that the George Maltby of the Magpie Mine might be the George Maltby of the Eyam Mining Company. Such details as I have been able to locate from various electronic sources are summarised below, including some from your own website, for which many thanks.
    Kind regards,
    Mike Clifford

    George Maltby 1796-1873

  • 1796 Possible submitted Mormon IGI Record of christening at Hope, Derbyshire. Parents Robert and Margaret
  • 1819 A George Maltby witnessed the Will of Robert Hall, Miner and Buddler of Bradwell, Derbyshire http://www.genuki.org.uk/big/eng/DBY/ProbateRecords/WillsH.html
  • 1820 A George Maltby of Foolow, Lead Miner, recorded as the composer of music for a Christmas Carol called 'Marshall' or 'Star of Bethlehem' in 'Alive and kicking: the living tradition of English ‘gallery’ music' by Ian Russell
  • 1823 Extracted Mormon IGI Record of marriage at Eyam, Derbyshire to Hannah Bankcroft
  • 1834 Possibly the George Maltby employed at the Magpie Mine and who was acquitted at Derby Assizes of a charge of murder in connection with the deaths of three miners by smoke inhalation at the Red Soil Mine.
  • 1841 Lead Miner living Cressbrook, Tideswell, Derbyshire. Four sons and six daughters in Household
  • 1851 Lead Miner living ****, Eyam, Derbyshire. Two sons, four daughters and one grandson in Household
  • 1856 June 7th Derbyshire Times records that Mr George Maltby was Toastmaster at Eyam Mining Company's Dinner at the Bull's Head Eyam for 70 employees who had roast beef and plum pudding
  • 1857 A George Maltby recorded in White's Directory as Agent for the Eyam Mining Company in connection with the Morewood Sough
  • 1861 Lead Miner living Water Lane, Eyam, Derbyshire. Two sons and two daughters in Household
  • 1862 George Maltby agent for Eyam Mining Company, Lead Miners, listed in White's Directory
  • 1864 George Maltby described as Agent in the Eyam Mining Company's Annual Report
  • 1871 Widowed Lead Mine Agent living Eyam, Derbyshire. A widowed daughter-in-law and a daughter in Household
  • 1873 Death registered Bakewell, Derbyshire. Record as born 1796

Compiled, formatted, hyperlinked, encoded, and copyright © 2008, All Rights Reserved.